March 20, 2006
An Expletive-Laden Night with Matt Pond PA
This review written by DCist Contributor Matt Sedlar
Washington, D.C., you should be ashamed of yourself. The all-ages crowd at the 9:30 Club on Saturday night may have turned local boy Matt Pond against us, and it might take flowers and an apology to get him to come back. How did this all happen? Let's recap.
The evening began with a subdued performance by Australia's Youth Group, a four-piece rock outfit with a lot of shimmer but no shine. While singer/guitarist Toby Martin's vocals rarely varied from standard Brit-rock fare (see: James, Coldplay, etc.), the rhythm section consisting of Danny Allen on drums and Patrick Matthews on bass managed to keep things flowing nicely. One particularly funny aside: Martin seemed in awe that Ray Davies would be playing the same stage on Monday. One would have been hard-pressed to find anyone in the crowd old enough to know who Ray Davies is, much less be a fan of The Kinks. The band even played one song that suspiciously came close to ripping off the chorus of Bob Dylan's "Like a Rolling Stone." For a band named Youth Group, in which each member looked a bit over age 30, most of their references -- intentional or not -- must have flown over the audience's heads. Did we fail to mention that the tweens were out in full force?
Matt Pond PA then took the stage, with Pond proudly announcing that he was conceived in the District. Don't let the PA fool you, though -- the man even has a soft spot for the Redskins. Thankfully, the band brought some energy to what began as a quiet evening. However, cracks started to emerge in between the songs. Some expletive-laden comments from audience members brought about some funny and witty reactions from Pond, but after every song it appeared as if the heckling was wearing him down. By the time somebody suggested the band play "Freebird," Pond nearly cracked, sarcastically promising a 23-minute version after the next song. He still covered most of the incessant heckling nicely, such as turning down requests for a cover of "Champagne Supernova" only to play the main theme from "Brokeback Mountain" while confessing he was not a gay cowboy. The band was tight and never missed a beat -- even when Pond abandoned his guitar after breaking a string at the beginning of one song. The recent addition of Dana Feder on cello also served to expand the songs past the typical guitar/bass/drums configuration.
So why did people find it necessary to constantly harass the band during the awkward silence in between songs? Should Pond leave the District remembering it as the city whose music fans requested Slayer at his show? Seriously, folks. Pond deserves an apology and an explanation. Let the healing process begin.





geez, if people want their music in nice little packages, they should stay home and listen to the CD on their stereo.
The heckling was a little strange. I was up in the balcony, so I couldn't make out a lot of what was being shouted. At least the music was good. I wish they could have played longer; the set came in at just over an hour, I think. I don't know if the shorter time onstage had anything to do with frustration on Pond's part, or the fact that the club had another event planned for 11 p.m.
I was at this concert, and I think you are way overstating things here as far as any heckling is concerned. Sure, people were talking in between songs, but I didn't see any "heckling," and I don't think that comments from the crowd between songs had any negative effect on the band. It seemed to me that the band was enjoying playing a good show in front of what was, for them, a really big crowd. I think Pond's comment towards the end of the show reflected this.
And as far as cover requests between songs, what's the big deal? Is it wrong to have a crowd that is engaged in the concert and that makes a little noise and has a little fun during a band's "awkward silence between songs"? It's not as if people were not paying attention to the music or were loud or disrespectful while the band was playing. And Pond seemed to have fun with it from everything I could see. The fact is that the band chose to record a cover of "Champagne Supernova" for "The O.C." and the result of that is it (1)attracts some "tween" element to their shows, as your point out, and (2) leads people to shout for them to play the song. They won't play it live, which is their choice. This has been documented in articles about the band, and it seems to me like they dealt with it fine.
begin rant.
when did matt pond pa get so big? i saw them open for liz phair in october at 9:30 and NOBODY there knew who they were (not to mention that there was really nobody there in general). and a few years ago i saw them play backstage at blackcat with 6 other people.
don't get me wrong, i am really excited for them that they are getting big and that music seems to be making a turn for the better recently. but the crowd did suck.
i think the only reason they had the early show was because all the kids there had to be home for there 11pm curfew.
as a note to anyone out there that reads this: people that shout "freebird" at concerts make asses out of themselves.
a note to people that actually shout out "freebird" at concerts: keep your mouth closed and SHUT THE F*CK UP, you sound stupid.
end rant.
Matt, good review, but took away totally different perception of the stage presence (complete disclosure: I was on the balcony)...whereas some performers can defuse heckling from--and even win over--a tough crowd, I just found Pond's banter kind of strange and grating. And to echo a previous post, it didn't seem like a tough crowd at all. I just wanted Pond to shut up and get back to playing Emblems et al.
He seems a bit uncomfortable on stage, but if you've seen him perform before, like when he was at Iota two years ago, or at the Black Cat a year ago, you'd know that that's par for the course. I think he's not really ready for as big a crowd as was there, he may be a bit uncomfortable with success. The recent hype of the OC and being mentioned in Rolling Stone probably lead to the larger crowds.
As for the heckling... what concerts doesn't that happen at? I think he handled it well, and I don't think any apologies are required.
And to the author, if you listen to more Matt Pond you'll realize that the cello isn't a new addition. The previous cellist, Eve Miller (http://www.squarehalo.org/images/blog/eve.jpg), had a large part in many previous albums, including many tracks on Emblems in which she sang along with Matt.