Quantcast

Weekly Columnist Roundup: Meat, Schools and Granola

writer.jpgWe read all the local columnists, so you don't have to. This week we find meat-eaters being compared to Michael Vick, a lot of bum opinions on city schools and District residents being called "granola."

Courtland Milloy: According to Milloy's Wednesday column in the Post, your choice to eat a hamburger isn't all that different than Michael Vick's decision to brutally fight, torture and kill dogs for money. "We'll kill a duck, deer, turkey -- name any meat -- for the sheer entertainment of our palates or for the fun of the hunt," he writes. While there's little doubt that we judge animals on how cute they are, how useful they are to us and whether or not we've been taught that it's OK to eat them, it's more than a stretch to say that Vick's actions aren't all that different than eating a chicken breast, grilling a steak or buying a salmon filet. At least Milloy makes it clear who he's going to pick for his fantasy football league next season.

Colbert King: The king -- pun intended -- of the District's columnists argued in his Sunday column that new school Chancellor Michelle Rhee faces but one big challenge in her quest to improve public education -- the school bureaucracy. "The central office fervently believes that the status quo is a blessed concept to be defended against all comers," he notes. "The central office has outlived superintendents, elected and appointed school board members, a congressionally created financial control board, an Army general, auditors and a rotating corps of inquiring reporters. Through it all, the central office has remained an incubator for incompetence, obstruction, cronyism and corruption." Hmm. Sound like something else we have here in Washington?

Tom Knott: It's a battle of the extremes, as our favorite right-wing hitman at the Washington Times takes on the ANSWER Coalition and their many fliers plastered around town. And in attacking the so-called "revolutionaries" at ANSWER, Knott gets in a little dig at us while defending the city's actions. He writes: "There are few places more granola than the nation's capital, where the denizens actually believe in the nut-job political messages found in the grocery aisles of Whole Foods, hold candlelight vigils for fallen trees and preach at the altar of multiculturalism from the safety of their highly segregated neighborhoods." If Knott thinks that the District is as granola as things get, he needs to climb out of his bunker and travel a little, shouldn't he?

Jonetta Rose Barras: The District's public school bureacracy just can't get a break this week, as the Examiner's Rose Barras attacks the rules that make hiring good people hard and firing bad people even harder. Like King, Rose Barras makes it clear that reform at the city's schools will only go as far and happen as fast as the bureaucracy allows it -- which may not be much, and not very quickly. "[E]veryone continues to talk about creating a student-centered public education system," she writes. "Watch out! They're blowing smoke."

Harry Jaffe: The other half of the Examiner's local politics columnist lineup, Jaffe used his space this week to tackle...the Redskins. Apparently Jaffe isn't happy with the quarterbacks Joe Gibbs has offered up over the last three seasons. "Why have Coach Joe Gibbs and Redskins owner Dan Snyder bet their entire season on the knee of a 26-year-old kid who’s started a few NFL games and won only one? Isn’t it time to ask these two geniuses why — with all the money Snyder throws at players — they can’t get a decent couple of quarterbacks?" Well, Harry, give the Redskins 12-18 months and a few years on top of that, and we know of one quarterback that'll be looking for a job.

Marc Fisher: We covered this yesterday, but it's worth mentioning again. Fisher -- yes, the same Marc Fisher that couldn't find enough good things to say about spending $611 million in public funds on a baseball stadium -- seems to be having second thoughts about the wisdom of such an investment. "There is still no guarantee that the D.C. experiment with baseball as economic development tool will work," he warns. "Yes, some very big developers are pumping very big money into the area, and yes, the plans look great on paper or on a computer screen. But the ultimate test of the new Southeast's success will be whether people come, and the declining attendance at RFK over the Nationals' first three years is not hugely encouraging."

Loose Lips: Even though the City Paper announced a replacement for former Loose Lips columnist James Jones, the column remains on hiatus. Sure, the D.C. Council is on vacation, but there's always enough Marion Barry for a few thousands words a week, right?

Contact the author of this article or email tips@dcist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]