Out of Frame: U23D

2008_0123_BonoCoexist.jpgFor those of you who have never had the pleasure of being right up close at a U2 concert, let me divulge a spoiler: Bono — a.k.a. Paul Hewson, a.k.a. The Fly, a.k.a Mr. MacPhisto, champion of Africa and two-time Nobel Prize nominee, debt-relief crusader and F-bomb-dropping bane of the Federal Communications Commission, the big-brained, big-hearted, big-mouthed and wholly unembarrassable front man for The (all together now!) World’s Biggest Band — is a wee, short little dude. Five-seven, five-eight, tops. When he performs — and truly, no rock and roll frontman has ever looked more at ease serenading a stadium-load of air guitarists than this guy — he wears thick-soled boots that give him an extra inch-and-a-half on the vertical plane. Every little bit helps, right?

But to paraphrase Al Capone, you can get further with a pair of platform shoes and a 3D IMAX film that captures your every messianic gesture in six story high close-up than you can with platform shoes alone.

Thus arrives U23D, the most unambiguously-titled movie since Alien vs. Predator. It’s an 85-minute concert film compiled from a half-dozen early 2006 stadium gigs from U2’s Vertigo Tour. (Two other concert DVDs from the Vertigo Tour have already come out, making it perhaps the most exhaustively-documented rock roadshow since Bono created the world in seven days. Oh, relax, would you? I'm kidding now.) Released through National Geographic exclusively in IMAX theaters, it's the first live-action film to be completely shot and edited using a digital 3D process that James Cameron helped to develop and is using to shoot Avatar, his post-Titanic return to features. The results are, from a purely technical perspective, extraordinary.

Photos courtesy U2

The images have a convincing illusion of depth, and the film’s sound design contributes to the immersive feel by discretely separating different vocal and instrumental sounds. On “Sunday Bloody Sunday”, for example, you hear Bono’s lead vocal in front of you and the Edge’s backing part somewhere behind your head. The sound design also emphasizes the rumble-in-the-gut feel of a concert over a pristine presentation of the music, allowing crowd noise to remain a constant presence in the mix. While no overdubs were added, Bono’s once-mighty vox, an uncertain quantity in recent years, gets a subtle assist, with the film’s audio selectively mixed to hide its limitations.

With their two world tours of the 1990s, Zoo TV and PopMart, U2 did more than any band ever had, practically or artistically, to compress the space of a football stadium into a place where something like intimacy was possible. So it makes sense that they’d want to try to advance the medium of the concert film in the same way. As co-directed by Catherine Owens and Mark Pellington, both longtime associates of the band, U23D errs on the side of taste, preferring long takes to the hyperactive jump cuts of many concert films and avoiding the eye-poking novelty of the other 3D movies you've seen. The “wipe your tears away” passage of “Sunday Bloody Sunday” is the only point I can recall at which Bono reaches out physically to “touch” the viewer. Otherwise, the 3-D effect is most striking in the crowd shots, wherein the sea of heads and arms seems to extend outward from the screen even as they vanish into a horizon of camera flashes and illuminated cell phones.

2008_0123_TheEdge.jpgPredictably, the songs included are mostly U2’s Greatest Hits — “Beautiful Day”, “Where the Streets Have No Name”, “One” — but a few worthy album tracks make the cut. Most notable is “Miss Sarajevo", the band’s 1995 elegy for that war-torn city. When Bono sings the Italian verse that Luciano Pavarotti performed on the recorded version, it’s one of the highlights in terms of sheer performance. Meanwhile, the unholy sonic mess that is the botched start of “The Fly” is one of the carefully-chosen moments of imperfection left in, like Adam Clayton’s bungled bass solo on “Gloria” from the Under a Blood Red Sky live EP a hundred years ago. (Okay, it was 1983, but you know.)

Bono’s sometimes eloquent, sometimes tiresome, always criticized sermonizing is all but absent, perhaps because all of the footage is from concerts in countries where English is not the native tongue. But the centerpiece of the Vertigo Tour shows, wherein “Sunday Bloody Sunday” segues into “Bullet the Blue Sky” while Bono dons a headband/blindfold bearing the command “Coexist”, with an Islamic crescent moon representing the “C”, a star of David the “X”, and a cross the “T”, is as powerful on film as it was in person. A few minutes later, when a recording of a woman reading the U.N.’s Declaration of Human Rights introduces “Pride (In the Name of Love)”, you might have to stop yourself from pumping your fist in righteous solidarity.

You’ll want to stay through the credits, which feature some cool animation effects left over, presumably, from the movie proper, as well as a live performance of “Yahweh”.

“You’re all so much smaller in real life,” Bono once told a concert audience. In U23D, the long-lived Irish quartet has finally found the film format to match their outsized ambition. The World's Biggest Band has become, beyond all argument, the world's biggest band. As in, quantifiably. Seems appropriate somehow.

U23D opens Jan. 23 at the National Museum of Natural History’s Johnson IMAX Theatre. Advance tickets are available here. The film, if you care, is rated G.

Email This Entry


Comments (22) [rss]

Miss Sarajevo is not a U2 song. But rather a song from the Passengers project with Brian Eno.

Miss Sarajevo Wiki

Miss Sarajevo is not a U2 song. But rather a song from the Passengers project with Brian Eno.

Miss Sarajevo Wiki

i know our TV channel uses that stupid contraction of our name in their promos, but please don't call us natgeo. NGS, or (god forbid), national geographic. but natgeo is about the lamest ass thing i've ever heard in my life. makes me embarrassed to work here (at least i don't work for the channel...)

i should have said "NGS, or (god forbid), national geographic is preferable." sorry that wasn't clear.

You want to get into U2 trivia with me? Okay, you asked for it!

*Sigh* Yes, you're right. "Miss Sarajevo" is actually the only thing much resembling a song on the 1995 Passengers: Original Soundtracks 1 album for which U2 served more-or-less as Brian Eno's backup band. Bono wrote the lyric and sings it, and all four members of U2 play on it -- all five, if you count Eno as an essential element of the band, as some do -- but the album is credited to Passengers. However, "Miss Sarajevo" was included on U2's The Best of 1990-2000 compilation disc, so I think that to call it a U2 song is fair.

Larry Mullen, Jr. is on record as despising the Passengers album. And I will now go on the record as saying that it's pretty forgettable, with the exception noted above.

I've heard the hype, and now I must see for myself. After this, can I finally say I've been to a U2 concert? I'm going with "yes."

I've heard the hype, and now I must see for myself. After this, can I finally say I've been to a U2 concert? I'm going with "yes."

Wow IMGoph. Got a dinosaur bone up your arse? I compliment your organization on something and you call my wording stupid? Nice! Have a beer. Relax. GO NATGEO!

i didn't call your wording stupid, brightlights, i called our organization stupid for using it. no need to tell me to relax...i'm already drugged up as it is today... :)

Um, did anyone else take offense to defining a 5'7" person as "wee, little short dude"? (I'm huge in Central America.)

I am 5'8". I consider 5'7" to be basically a Hobbit.

perhaps he's "wee" by ireland's standards?

He's 5 foot 8 in AOL chatrooms maybe. Otherwise he's just damn short.

Look, the guy's annoying as hell. But he's quite earnest, and works his ass off doing a ton more than most famous people ever will.

And, yes, we all like the old U2. But some of the new stuff ain't bad, and regardless they do put on a great live show. But visually they do need to mix it up. The Edge has become a visual caricature, what with hiding his baldness with the caps and all.I say, Edge, put on some assless chaps. That'll draw attention away from the bald...

Um, did anyone else take offense to defining a 5'7" person as "wee, little short dude"? (I'm huge in Central America.)

Not really, I come from a family of big Lurches; GrandpaRat was 6'8", DadRat is 6'6", and I'm the midget at 6'3". 5'7" is indeed a "wee, little short dude"

Actually I'm 5'9". Average human male height. 5'7" seemed to be a normal height when I walked the streets of Dublin. I'm guessing Chris is other 6'2" and thinks that is average, or has a chip on his shoulder. :) Regardless, that is pretty obnoxious that Mr. Klimek would call him a wee, short little dude.

The Irish are not a tall people, but I think 5'7" would still be on the short side (I'm 5'7" and I seem to remember most Irish men being taller than me, although not by much.)

The bigger question is why people get so offended when it's pointed out to them that they're short. Whatever. It's like me getting mad at someone for pointing out that my eyes are green. Some people are short and some people are tall. Not much you can do about it.

Reminds me of this guy I used to date who was not overly tall. My friend Angela called him "the wee chef from Belfast." He was indeed wee (5'5") and he didn't take offense. Of course, he also didn't get offended when I referred to him as my leprechaun, which is wrong on so many levels, so maybe he was just hard to offend.

Oh, for crying out loud . . .

My apologies to anyone who took offense at me characterizing the shortest and most famous member of U2 as -- what was the highly-charged epithet I used? -- oh yeah: "short."

(Here's a Wonkette item about a Bush-Bono sit-down that refers to The Fly as a "feisty leprechaun" if you want a real Bono slur to cry about.)

What really matters here (if any of this matters) is that Bono thinks of himself as short. Evidence: The platform shoes. Evidence: The narrator's joke on the 2001 Elevation Tour live DVD from Boston about how if a cinematographer wants to keep getting hired to film U2 concerts, he should choose lenses that make Bono look as tall as possible. Evidence: The anecdote in Bill Flanagan's 1995 book U2 at the End of the World wherein Flanagan talks about how Bono refers to Robert Plant as "the tall, cool one" and then gets really, really upset when he hears that Plant called him "the short, fat one." Then again, maybe it was being called "fat" that had Bono all broken up. Well, that and all those starving Africans.

Bono wishes he was taller. I wish I was the singer in a globally-adored rock band. You can't always get what you want.

The Vertigo tour is far from the most exhaustively documented tour in rock history. Pearl Jam, for example, released has released discs (or, more recently, downloadable MP3/FLAC archives) documenting pretty much every live concert they've done since 2000; some of those tours thus have upwards of 70 CDs of documentation.

I don't know if it's sadder that I know this much about Pearl Jam, or that I have no trouble believing that there are fanboys who own every one of those releases.

Dude (Sweth),

Go to the dictionary a look up the word "hyperbole" for me, would you? Bono didn't really create the Earth, either.

But if you insist on taking everything literally, let's do. My understanding is that what Pearl Jam done with their "authorized bootlegs" is simply release the raw soundboard audio of those shows, with little or none of the editing, overdubbing, and mastering that typically goes into "live" recordings before they're officially released. Many bands record all of their concerts for their own archival purposes. I know for a fact that U2 do -- at least that's what Joe O'Herlihy, who has run live sound for them since the 80s, told me.

In any case, it's a much more complicated, expensive, time-consuming deal to shoot and edit a concert film (and the two Vertigo concert DVDs were shot on film, not video, which only adds to the time and cost) than it is to release soundboard audio that you're probably recording anyway. That U2 have done it three times for a single tour is surely overkill. But I bought both of the prior Vertigo Tour DVD releases (one of which was only available as a bonus DVD packaged with the deluxe edition of the U218 compilation), so I'm only encouraging their penchant for excess, I suppose.

I think it's pretty cool that Pearl Jam do that, by the way. I hear they change up their setlist every night, so the ready availability of a souvenir copy of whichever concert you happened to see (or indeed, whichever concert you're sorry you missed) is great for their fans.

Um. Chris. I believe the term you used was "wee, short little dude." A tad different than calling someone short. No? You just sound like someone on the playground who is over average height and feels the need to feel superior to someone. But I'm guessing you're average height or shorter. Right? And did you really reference Wonkette for your argument? Part of the snarkiest, meanest media group on the planet? Culture of bile anyone? http://nymag.com/news/features/39319/index1.html

And Esmeralda...assuming you're female, you're about three inches taller than average US female height. It is not about calling someone short. Let us take skin color for example. It is one thing to call someone a
"black dude." Would it not be a little, uh, disconcerting to call someone a "black ebony darkie dude"? And the guy you dated...maybe he didn't get offended for other reasons? How about you ask him why he didn't get offended? Oh wait. "Used to date" Oops.

Um. Chris. I believe the term you used was "wee, short little dude." A tad different than calling someone short. No? You just sound like someone on the playground who is over average height and feels the need to feel superior to someone. But I'm guessing you're average height or shorter. Right?

Gosh, Brightlights, I didn't know you cared! Since you asked, I'm 6'1" and 195 lbs., but thank you for playing. I'm actually trying to train down by about 20, as I'm more competitive as a light-heavyweight than I am as a crusierweight.

As much as you seem to want to give me credit (blame) for the stunning (factual) observation that Bono is short, I'm afraid I'm neither the first nor the 101st writer to say so. I've been reading U2's press coverage since The Joshua Tree came out. That Bono is of compact stature on the Y-axis is treated pretty much as anecdotal "fact," in the same way it's accepted as anecdotal "fact" that he can be a mite preachy sometimes.

That said, I'm sincerely sorry I upset you. I'll go ahead and add "wee," "short," and "little" to my banned list of inflammatory adjectives right away. To quote another famous short guy with a big head, Good grief!

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

About DCist

DCist is a website about Washington, D.C. More

Editor: Sommer Mathis Publisher: Gothamist

Twitter

Contribute

Latest Tip:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZSSSLEG_hRk&feature=player_embedded
[more]

Latest Photo:

Recent Comments

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from DCist.

All Our RSS