DCist T-Shirts
dcistshirt.jpg
About DCist

DCist is a website about Washington, D.C. More

Editor: Sommer Mathis Publisher: Gothamist

About | Advertising | Archive | Contact | Mobile | Photos | Staff | Subscribe

Categories
Favorites
Contribute

Latest tip:

I came across a site that often features lovely historic photos of DC, such as this photo of a U [more]

 

Latest link:

 

Latest Photo:

 

Recent Comments
Subscribe
Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from DCist.
Overheard
Voting Rights
Public Calendar
Links

July 8, 2008

Woman Killed by Garbage Truck in Dupont Updated

2008_0708_accident.jpg

The AP is reporting that a 22-year-old woman has died after being struck by a garbage truck while riding her bicycle near Dupont Circle this morning. The garbage truck, which was not owned by the city but rather a private company, struck the woman at Connecticut and R Streets NW just before 8:30 a.m. The roadway around the accident site was shut down while officers investigated the scene. The woman has not yet been identified.

UPDATE 11:18 a.m.: Reader Giacomo Abrusci sends in some images of the scene of the accident. You can see the outline of where the woman was struck in the pedestrian crosswalk at 20th and R Streets above. The Post also has a story up now with a chilling quote from Fire and EMS spokesperson Alan Etter: "The truck just ran completely over her," Etter said. The truck was owned by KMG Hauling Inc., a company based in Sterling. It's still not clear whether this driver was working on a job for the city or a private residence or business.

2008_0708_accident2.jpg

Email This Entry







Advertisement: DCist Continues Below!

Comments (120) [rss]

oh no. very sad. the city will still likely be on the hook. well, as long as the truck was on city business and not hijacked by joyriding tourists or something.

 

Actually, according to the story on the Post, which is much better than the linked to AP story, it was a private hauler who struck the cyclist. Whether or not they were working for the city at the time is unclear (according to the paper).

 

oh boy, this is terrible. my thoughts go out to her family and friends.

how fast was the truck going? i looked at the post and WTOP articles, and the details are not clear. i'm assuming she was in the bike lane there. could the truck have made a right turn into her without seeing her there?

 

How awful! Vaughan, I think it's a bit early to say the city will be on the hook. The garbage truck though could've been hired to pick up from dumpsters at condos and such.

 

Bravo WTOP Comment Board. It only took you one post to be incredibly offensive.

As for the city's liability, obviously there are few facts out there, but I can't see how the city would be liable for a private garbage truck. I think most private garbage trucks, like Tenleytown Trash, contract directly with the apartment buildings they service. It's not like they're subcontractors of the city.

 

There's a bike lane there on R street at Connecticut ave - likely where this occurred. This is what happens in a city where there's little-to-no enforcement of traffic laws. The trash truck that killed her was operated by kmG Hauling out of VA - probably a private hauler for one of the restaurants in the area there.

 

you're right, drew. i made a snap assumption there. my bad!

 

oh no! so sad!

 

this happened about 4 cars in front of me on my commute this morning (had to drive down the alley behind Cosi). based on my experience, those garbage truck drivers pay very little attention to their immediate surroundings.

 

The Post story provides actual details. Sounds like she wasn't just struck, she was plain run over. WTF.

 

Oh, that's awful. My heart goes out to her family. I was wondering what happened, I was on the L2 bus going down 18th street and saw the street blocked off.

 

This is simply awful.

Once again, our traffic management systems are in conflict with good practices nationwide in terms of managing our resources to the benefit of cyclists and pedestrians.

Once again, we ask, when will the City wake up and get it together?

The Master Bicycle and Pedestrian Plans are good starts but are a mere drop in the bucket where good policy is concerned.

I am sure the politicians will use this opportunity to lament the situation, but until our leadership starts to put its foot down and draw the line on best practices, crap like this will continue.

These are tragedies which can be avoided, or at least mitigated.

 

I walked by the scene around 10... the truck was still in the intersection, although it had probably been moved a bit, it was still pointed in the northbound direction on 20th... based on comment 9, I suspect that the girl was headed straight through the intersection in the bike lane on the right hand side of R while the truck was turning north onto 20th from R... which would take it right across the bike lane...

did the truck signal its turn? could the girl have seen it? regardless, it's a damned shame... and why does it seem that garbage trucks are involved in a disproportionate percentage of pedestrian accidents?

 

I wonder if it was a metro bus driver moonlighting as a trash hauler....

 

i'm not defending anyone or saying who's at fault, but the crosswalk where the accident happened has always been dangerous (between Tomate and the Scientology Church). pedestrians/bikers are always crossing when they don't have a walk signal. something like this was just waiting to happen.

 

Only 22 years old =(

I've just begun using my bike as my primary means of transportation in DC, and as more people make the same decision I do we as a city need to work on ensuring safety on the road for all pedestrians and cyclists.

 

McGillcuddy--
Nice how you are not defending anyone or saying who's at fault, but still manage to cast blame on the deceased victim. Very classy. As long as we're jumping to conclusions without any data, it looks like the most logical conclusion is the classic "right hook" scenario that Captain Easychord describes. And as long as drivers don't look for pedestrians and cyclists with the right of way right hooks are just waiting to happen.

 

I walked past the scene this morning and was incredibly saddened. This is a tragedy.

That being said, without knowing the facts, we cannot assume that the driver was at fault or that the intersection is poorly designed or maintained.

As a pedestrian, and non-car owner, in the Dupont area, I have seen nearly daily occurences of outrageous, illegal and dangerous riding by cyclists. I've nearly been run over more than a few times by cyclists. And I've seen law abiding drivers cut off and accidents nearly occur because of cyclists who believe laws and common sense do not apply to them.

While it is key that the city take responsibility for pedestrian, cyclist and auto safety in the district, it also key that cyclists also take responsibility for their own safety. Stop running red lights, stop swerving through intersections, stop cutting cars off, stop riding at breakneck speeds down sidewalks.

Before we know the facts of this accident, let's just remark that is a tragedy without assigning blame.

 

easychord, I've driven a Ryder truck. and it has awful blind spots. Trucks in general have no rear view mirror, so it's hard for them to see. Not apologizing, just answering why they might be involved in so many collisions.

 

@McGillicuddy: Your statement completely moronic and, in regards to this tragedy, entirely speculative. Use your brain for once before making a comment; maybe then will you learn not to piss people off.

 

So how's a "master plan" supposed to fix this? We've got a plan now. It's called "look both ways." Doesn't seem like anybody, walking/biking/driving, pays attention to that. And when's the last time you saw a cop pull someone over for jaywalking or running a red light? Enforcing traffic laws is at the bottom of the cops' list, down there with issuing curb-your-dog fines and harassing loiterers.

Between 600-700 bicycle fatalities occur every year throughout the U.S., which is nothing compared to traffic fatalities as a whole. If you want fewer vehicle related fatalities downtown, you need fewer vehicles on the roads.

 

I have had trash trucks nearly back into my car in that area more times than I can count. A large part of their perceived carelessness is the fact that once their route is completed, they're done for the day--so there is an incentive to work as fast as possible. Not saying that this was the case here, b/c the facts simply aren't available...but I have seen reckless disregard for traffic laws by both cyclists and trash truck drivers. This is all very, very sad...

 

hey, i'm just saying that it's a dangerous intersection and am not surprised that an accident like this happened. i'm not saying it's the victim's fault or the driver's fault, but i'll tell you this - it's probably one of their faults. or maybe we should just blame the Church of Scientology.

 

did the truck signal its turn? could the girl have seen it? regardless, it's a damned shame... and why does it seem that garbage trucks are involved in a disproportionate percentage of pedestrian accidents?

My general feeling of that intersection is you can't see if cars are signaling from Connecticut Ave because of that street's angle and the slight straightaway that occurs on 20th before actually getting to R Street, and cars parked along the street there.

 

That intersection is no better or worse than 16th and New Hampshire or Connecticut and K or anwhere around Dupont: NOBODY pays attention to ANYTHING outside of their own tiny world. It's like when people have been sitting around waiting long enough, traffic signals and Dont Walk signs just become optional.

 

I just read the comments on WP and the one (by the lady who claims that everything I do to be safe and increase my visibility is actually just unsafe and me trying to enrage her into an accident) gets me to wondering:
Do VA, DC, and MD require ANY knowledge of Bike laws in order to get a driver's license? I am becoming a huge proponent of retesting - universal retesting, for you and me and everyone, not just for the aged. Which, even that last was shot down here in DC, so there are no mandatory retesting laws to keep driving. IF THERE WERE, we'd have a tool for perhaps increasing driver (and cyclist) understanding of the real laws of the street. As it is, most drivers and cyclists alike drive in a sort of limbo, public trust sort of way, hoping we agree enough on the rules not to kill anyone.
I'm already a paranoid cyclist (because I carry a toddler on my bike with me), but reading that entitlement rant scared me just that much more.

 

just this morning, i thought about starting to commute to work by bicycle (rather than take the bus), when i noticed bikers using bike lanes on 17th street downtown.

i think i'll put that idea on hold now....

 

all of us are trying to get everywhere as quickly as we can. i move fast when i'm on a bike, and i know cars move as quickly as they can without turning the street into a formula one race. we all just need to slow down.

maybe what the city needs is for everyone to just get high and relax, eh?

 

That's just a real shame, regardless of blame or wrongdoing or anything. :(

 

Sophiagrrl, I think there may be one question on the written test. But, of course so many people in DC waive in from out of state...I think retesting is a great idea (at my job I have to retest every year on how not to give away my password or sexually harass my co-workers - clearly they have not seen my co-workers) and I think cyclist/motorist insurance with lower rates for those who take a 'confident cyclist' course is a great idea too.

 

Quoth McGillicuddy:

maybe we should just blame the Church of Scientology.

I can get behind that.

But seriously, I think I can agree on every single point in this post. Some cyclists are reckless, some pedestrians are reckless as are some drivers. The cops don't enforce traffic laws unless they feel like it. But instead of bitching about it here, how many of us are going to write a council member or the mayor demanding REAL action?

 

Not placing blame here but I must say that I'm frequently amazed at the behavior of some cyclists. There have been a few occassions when I am proceeding to make a right turn, checked the mirrors, used turn signal etc. and out of nowhere a cyclist tries to squeeze between my car and the curb just as I'm making the turn. Not very smart.

 

Why doesn't the city restrict trash pickup to the early morning hours to prevent these behemoths from tooling around the city during rush hour?

 

@monkeyerotica...the problem is, the city can write all the master plans and flush whatever millions of dollars down the commode it wants. The irony is that DDOT has had a pilot pedestrian signal in upper northwest for the past 18 months or so.

There has not been one accident at the intersection, nor any pedestrian incidents in that time. Yet, what does the city do? It announces that the signal will become a traditional signal because of near misses viewed in 96 hours of video collected in October 2007 and because drivers get frustrated and drive through a red light.

You would think with the number of pedestrian fatalities and injuries and tragedies like this morning (not to mention the deliberate attempts to curtail commuting single occupancy vehicles, as noted by Eric Weiss in the Post) that the city would be lauding this advancement.

To eliminate the signal simply demonstrates the lack of commitment by DDOT to these progressive policy initiatives in favor of, yes, drivers, who are generally the same ones who comment that the pedestrians and bicyclists should get out of their damned way.

 

NotTheRedBaron--
Assuming that the light is green and there is no stop sign, when a car is turning right and a cyclist is traveling straight in the same/adjacent lane the cyclist has the right of way.

 

demonfafa says...

But instead of bitching about it here, how many of us are going to write a council member or the mayor demanding REAL action?
what "real action" would prevent a situation like this? stepped up enforcement of traffic laws might help a little, but ultimately monkey has the answer here:
So how's a "master plan" supposed to fix this? We've got a plan now. It's called "look both ways." Doesn't seem like anybody, walking/biking/driving, pays attention to that.

 

What a tragedy.

More generally, I have to agree with IMGoph and demonfafa that we're all to blame. As a pedestrian, I've had cars almost mow me down (when they had stop signs - forget trying to cross at a designated crosswalk that lacks a stop sign or light), I've seen bicycles stupidly cut off cars, and there have been a few times where I could have gotten myself killed trying to dash across a street and was saved by an alert driver stopping just in time. Maybe the cops just need to issue more citations. I think that would motivate me.

 

Why doesn't the city restrict trash pickup to the early morning hours to prevent these behemoths from tooling around the city during rush hour?


Because most people I know don't want to be woken up by the sound of trash trucks loading at 3am.

 

I think retesting is a great idea


As a driver, I will happily submit to retesting as soon as every single bike in the city is registered as a vehicle and every single bike rider is required to have a license to operate his or her "vehicle." You want to "share the road?" Fine, then get licensed and registered like the rest of us.