July 17, 2008
Transit on Thursday: The Full of Sound and Fury Edition
Jim Graham's hearing on the Anacostia streetcar project has come and gone - the results? Everything's pretty much the way it was before. Barring any last minute legislative derailments, the Anacostia line should go on as planned. There is, however, a small new can of worms opening. The debate centers around whether or not the line will actually achieve anything other than pushing forward streetcar development to other parts of the city. Some transit types claim that without the Anacostia line, you'll never see a streetcar on H Street NE - without a doubt the place to put a line in the city - and that if this is the cost to get a line there, then so be it. Others say that it's foolish to force a line in Anacostia, when Columbia Pike's streetcar could be just as, if not more successful. Others are simply stuck in between, keeping the faith that either way will lead to more options.
We suppose we'll have to wait and see. Groundbreaking is scheduled for the fall - feel free to let us know what you think about the Anacostia line's merits in the comments.
Whaddya Have To Do To Get A Decent Pass Around Here?: We were intrigued by this New York Times article about the tenth anniversary of the unlimited-ride MetroCard for New York's subway. Not to get in to the whole MTA vs. Metro brouhaha again, but this is one program that Metro could probably emulate to positive results. To wit: in New York, you can buy a seven-day, unlimited-ride, any mode of transit MetroCard for $25. Here, you can buy a 7-day Metro pass - but, a) it's only good for rail trips, b) it's not compatible with SmartTrip (so, good luck if you need to park and keep track of both your pass and your SmartTrip card), and c) it costs $39. If you want to be able to transfer to a bus, a weekly bus pass will run you another $11. Finally, (as if this could be any more complicated), you can purchase a "short trip" pass, which is only valid during rush hours and trips of up to $2.65 - for $26.40. Did we mention that none of this is SmartTrip compatible?
Photo by pictureprefect
The Times article found that every level of unlimited-ride MetroCard user pays, on average, less than the regular $2 fare - even dipping as low as $1.45 per ride for high-volume riders. Of course, since Metro's fares are dynamic based on distance, it's a bit different - but there's nothing saying that giving a slight fare discount to those who ride the train the most is a bad idea. Heck, if you use your SmartTrip card on a Metrobus, you get a ten cent discount already. Just because our fare structure is different, it's no excuse for pass buying to take an hour of homework and wallet-shuffling to figure out.
If we can take anything from the comparison, it's this: people are clamoring to use mass transit more than ever, and we should facilitate their willingness to do so - if the economics work out.
Metro's Not The Only Transit Agency Setting Records, You Know: Sure, Metro might be setting new records right and left, but it's not the only transit agency doing so. Virginia Railway Express had seven of its highest ridership days ever in June, and like Metro, is quickly facing a capacity crisis. According to WTOP, VRE had plans to add seven new locomotives to pull longer trains of up to ten cars. Sounds nice, eh? But since the General Assembly failed to pass a transportation bill, the $25 million set to go to VRE improvements is nothing more than a number on a piece of paper. The result is that the 17,000 riders per day of VRE might have to wait a little bit longer to grab a train in the morning - a pertinent reminder that if Metro ridership continues to grow at a breakneck pace, a similar situation might not be too far off for a lot more of us.
Engines and Cabooses: Dr. Gridlock has the recap on Tuesday night's community meeting about the 16th Street bus revamps... Md. Gov. Martin O'Malley wants to convert all MTA buses to hybrids - currently, only ten of the fleet's 653 buses are hybrids... Prince William and Loudon Counties to increase bus fares due to gas prices... Gov. Tim Kaine encourages Va. workers to telecommute... Greenbelt wants more bus service.




[ report this ]
Just started a job that has me taking MARC and Metro and I was really disappointed how flimsy the TransitLink Card pass was. I entered in my SmartTrip card # on their website but I think that was just for smartbenefits or something, I was hoping I'd be able to use the SmartTrip card for the Metro part of my commute.
[ report this ]
Short Trip pass is valid at all times. The "short trip" part of it ($2.65 limit) only applies during peak periods.
[ report this ]
Okay, but what does Columbia Pike have to do with anything? Aren't the Anacostia and H Street lines a DC government initiative, and not Virginia? I mean, if Va. wants to pony up some dough, then there's a discussion to be had. I'm all for regional planning if everyone in the region wants to get on board.
[ report this ]
mikeb: that's the thing, there used to be regional planning, and that was wmata's bailiwick. since they finished the original metro lines (the approx. 103 miles of it), they disbanded that office. too bad...
[ report this ]
@Q:
Maryland is working on adopting the SmarTrip card for all MTA services, including MARC, commuter bus, and Baltimore region services. In addition to Metro, it is currently accepted on ART, CUE, DASH, Fairfax Connector, PRTC, and Ride On in addition to MetroBus, MetroRail and the DC Circulator. The delay is more political and fiscal than technological, so the day will come. Maybe even in our lifetimes.
[ report this ]
What would be nice would be if SmartTrip worked like EasyPass, where it automatically takes $25 out of my bank account or credit card when I run low. That would be sweet. And a discount off the regular fare wouldn't hurt.
[ report this ]
OK Here's a trip I had to take recently:
Return trip:
- SmarTrip card
- Rail pass
- Paper bus transfer
- 45 cents cash in exact change
Does this make sense to anybody?London has the Oyster Card that is good on the Tube, trams, buses, DLR, London Overground, and is being expanded to commuter trains. You can put a weekly or monthly pass on it. If you don't have a pass, there is a daily maximum fare. You can also see what it has charged you on their web site. No cash, no bother, and you don't have to guess first thing in the morning if you'd be better off with a pass.
[ report this ]
If I remember correctly from my time in London (pre-Oyster card), you could buy monthly passes based on a zone system.
Metro could do the same thing and create a Zone 1 (district proper), Zone 2 (closer suburbs), Zone 3 (outer suburbs). If you want a monthly pass for unlimited bus and rail travel in a single zone the cost could be $X, two zones X plus $20, all three zones X + $40 or something similar. If you had a Zone 1 pass only and wanted to go to Zone 3, the system could deduct the regular fare from the start of Zone 2 to your destination in Zone 3 from your SmartTrip card. It recognizes the variable pricing (to some extent) but also lets people “buy in bulk.â€
I also think that a pass would also keep more cars off the road. Once you have paid the monthly fee, the choice of whether to drive or take transit for a weekend trip or errand weighs in favor of transit more strongly because trips in addition to your regular commute are now “free.â€
[ report this ]
Hmm. I'm not sure why my comment appears like that. The formatting in the preview window was right.
And for dank, London's Oyster Card will automatically "top-up" just like the EasyPass.
[ report this ]
I spoke with WMATA earlier this year and earlier today about passes and Smartrip. I have a call in to discuss more details, but here's what I've found out so far:
WMATA is working on integrating passes into Smartrip. You would be able to load passes into your Smartrip account, as well as maintain an account balance for any trips that you don't have passes for.
They are working on automatic renewal of passes under a subscription system, as well as automatically recharging your card when it gets below a certain amount, or when you choose to load more funds at local establishments (he mentioned Giant grocery stores), or online.
We specifically discussed the short rail pass, which is good for trips under a certain dollar value. He stated that the desired function would be for the pass to work automatically, with any overage automatically deducted from your cash value "purse".
All of these options would be under the current approved fare structure, so no new discounts, changes in prices or anything are being anticipated, only integration with Smartrip.
The timeframe for this is "written in pencil", which he clarified as meaning subject to change at any time. The timeframe currently is sometime in 2009.
[ report this ]
@lp2k:
Yes, London still has the zone system. It makes the maps a bit more complicated, but they are still pretty easy to understand, and it works just fine with the Oyster card.
The advantage to this system (and the reason it won't happen) is suburbanites would end up paying more for their longer bus rides.
The beauty of the MetroRail system is that we essentially have a zone system, but lots of people have no idea how much they are paying for a trip, they just know how much is left on their fare card.
[ report this ]
If no one rides the anacostia streetcar, because it really doesn't go anywhere people want to go, will it be a failure and thus we never get a H street streetcar? (or in my humble opinion, a street car where it is really needed? Try 16th Street, Wisconsin Avenue, Pennsylvania Avenue, Independence Ave, etc.)