July 24, 2008
Cops Ticket Cyclists at New Hampshire and U Street

The intersection of U Street, 16th Street and New Hampshire Ave. in Northwest has long been a perilous spot for pedestrians and cyclists alike. It's just a weird confluence of two major thoroughfares plus a diagonal avenue that runs one-way, in opposite directions, for one block only on either side. If you've ever tried to cross U Street on foot there, you know just how unpredictable the flow of traffic can be. Last year DDOT was even considering cutting off vehicle access to New Hampshire from the intersection in an effort to make the crosswalks less dangerous.
So it is with mixed feelings that we post this photo and account from reader Travis Moore, who was caught in a bicycle road trap set up by the MPD on the section of New Hampshire Ave. that runs one-way northeast from the intersection this week (take a look at the spot here). Cops were out issuing tickets to cyclists who were heading down the block in the wrong direction. Says Moore:
"...while I understand the need to address the perceived problems of “scofflaw cyclists,” ticketing people on that stretch of road is a highly irrational response. I understand that it’s a one way street, and that in most cases, riding down a one way is dangerous and shouldn’t be attempted. But anyone who bikes in the city will tell you that if you’re heading south towards Dupont Circle from the U St corridor, this street is the only stretch of road which is even moderately safe to ride on. There are zero bike lanes that offer an alternative route.I've definitely ridden the wrong way down this block, so I know what Moore is talking about. Riding south on 16th Street in that area during rush hour can be quite scary. But then again, 14th Street does have a bike lane, and is far easier to navigate legally. Add in the already confusing and dangerous nature of this intersection, and it's hard to say for sure whether cyclists coming through from a street that should not be producing traffic from that direction are doing the right thing here.By ticketing people on that stretch the DC police is effectively mandating that cyclists take to either 14th or 16th streets, which are two of the busiest roads in the district, and on which cars (and trucks and commuter buses) frequently traveling at speeds of over 50 mph. It’s just insane. I’m all for encouraging biking by the rules, but this isn’t smart policy. It’s downright dangerous, in fact."
What do you think about Moore's argument? Is ticketing cyclists on this block a good step toward making this intersection less chaotic? Or is the MPD being overzealous in this case?




[ report this ]
I think he's absolutely right. The only way to really be safe riding is to avoid the traffic. Bikers should be able to do that anyway possible. I can't count the number of times I've almost died around that area b/c of cabs doing illegal U turns or people just speeding. Tell you what...if this happens to me...I'm running.
[ report this ]
Ride the sidewalk on this section of New Hampshire. If it's not in the CBD, it's not illegal.
Begin flaming in 3... 2... 1...
[ report this ]
this makes me happy for two reasons:
1. our police officers are actually doing something other than sitting in front of the 7 Eleven.
2. bikers in this town break traffic laws nonstop! stop signs? f*&! 'em. one way streets? who cares? and then when you almost hit them with your car as they run a stop sign or traffic light, they give you and evil stare or flip you off as if you were the one at fault.
i say the more tickets given to disobedient bikers the better.
*ducks and runs for cover*
[ report this ]
This city is absolutely farking ridonkulous. You've got to be kidding me. My tax dollars are paying for this?
[ report this ]
I'm with GhettoBurbs--since they changed the traffic pattern in front of the new Harris Teeter to make Kalorama NW one-way, I've been biking on the sidewalk.
I'm also with Moore's argument--this is the absloute wrong response by MPD to the traffic issue around that intersection.
[ report this ]
cyclists = Union Station photographers = terrorists.
[ report this ]
I'm a bike commuter and I started riding this block of NH after my previous route felt too unsafe.
I have never felt great about riding the wrong way on that street, but I didn't know of any good alternatives - the sidewalk's not a bad suggestion.
However, w/r/t to the 14th st. comment - 14th is only safe below U st. ABOVE that point, it gets a rating of "poor" on the DC bike map. Columbia Heights folks (and those north of that) have an extremely difficult time connecting all of the safe routes into 1 continuous route downtown. The best I could do was include a very unsafe section Florida and the one-way section of NH into my otherwise very safe route.
[ report this ]
McGillicuddy - By that rationale, shaking down hookers is "doing something" instead of loitering at 7-11.
The heirarchy of traffic ticketing goes like this:
1. Moving violations
2. Parking violations
3. Bike violations
4. Pedestrian violations
5. Shaking down hookers
I'd have no problem with 3 so long as they're spending proportionally more time on 1 and 2. The 5 they need to farm out to a locally owned private contractor. Like, say, E-Rotic Solutions, Ltd. (A Wholly Owned Subsidiary of Halliburton, Inc.)
Here's my card.
[ report this ]
And that cop looks like he's been spending a little too much time at Cakelove. Somebody get his ass on a bike patrol STAT.
[ report this ]
It's cool as long as the rules are applied to everyone. we'll see what hapens, but I strongly doubt any drives will be ticketed for running stops, invading the crosswalk, etc. The auto lobby is much stronger than WABA.
[ report this ]
monkey, i'm all for shaking down hookers, but i wouldn't be surprised if our fine police force interpreted that as meaning 'dancing with them under the sheets'.
and i agree that they should give out more moving/parking violations, particularly to our insane posse of cab drivers (and anyone with VA or MD plates). i just feel like bikers in this town want their cake and to eat it too.
[ report this ]
I don't know.
As a cyclist, I think this is fine. Going through stop signs and red lights when it's completely clear are okay—I really believe—but biking on a one-way-street is not cool.
I've been riding the correct way on a one-way and have been approached by another cyclist going in the wrong direction on the same side of the street. There wasn't enough room for both of us.
[ report this ]
Just because you're on a bike doesn't mean you get to ignore all the rules. The roads would be a lot safer for EVERYONE (including PEDESTRIANS, who often have to weave through bikers and cars, both of whom are being navigated by people who believe they have the right to run the road their way and screw everyone else) if people would just suck it up and follow the traffic laws. And that means not biking the wrong way down a one-way street.
I'm sick of bikers getting off easy because they're on bikes. I've almost been killed and/or pushed into traffic by bikers far more often than drivers. And the times I've had bad encounters with drivers is usually the product of their attempts to avoide reckless bikers. I'm often on FOOT in DC, because I don't like to drive in the city. I take the metro, then I WALK. Who's looking out for me?
Seriously, bikers, stfu.
[ report this ]
F**k is the point of even HAVING a cake if you can't eat the muthaf***er? F**k is that s**t all about? What the hell am I supposed to do with this s**t? Look at it? Put it on the mantle? Put little doilies around it. Hell NO! I'm going to eat the f**k out of that muthaf***er!
This is like motorcycle helmet laws. All the bikers get pissy when the nanny state tells them to wear a helmet. So they get rid of the helmet law and most of the pissy bikers end up wearing one ANYWAY. So I say fuggit. You want to risk being roadkill? Fine. Knock yourself out. Literally. All over the damned road. Because when you put your hand into a bunch of goo that was your best friends' FACE, then you'll know. Aw, forget it Jake. It's Chinatown.
[ report this ]
This reminds me of when, about a year and half ago, MPD began ticketing jaywalkers after incidents where pedestrians got run over. Even though the victims were not themselves jaywalking when they got run over.
[ report this ]
who bikes slow enough through stop signs to be stopped by a cop?
lame.
pedal faster.
[ report this ]
As an FYI, as part of the 16th Street Corridor Study, the District Department of Transportation is strongly considering allowing two way bike traffic on both one way sections of New Hampshire Ave (one north of U, one south of U) to accomodate what is clearly a desireable route for cyclists. In the meantime, it is illegal for cyclists to ride against traffic on any one way street.
If you use that route to get to Dupont, we recommend turning right on V, crossing 16th and turning left onto 17th then right on NH. It's a bit out of the way, but the route is on low volume streets and completely legal.
If you are unclear of the laws as they relate to cyclists, we have an excellent pocket guide to DC bike laws that's available at http://www.waba.org/wabastore/. Soon these will be distributed at all police district stations and we hope will be distributed to the police themselves. DC bike maps with designated bike routes are also available.
Eric
WABA
[ report this ]
Are they going to start ticketing riders for not having bells on their bikes, too?
This is ridiculous. Only once in DC have I seen a car pulled over for anything other than DWB. Cars drive the wrong way down Ives Pl SE after dropping off their kids at school (most have MD plates, FYI, they are "The Devil") and not once have I seen an officer give a second look... Can't we put this officer in Trinidad where he's needed?
[ report this ]
hey rules is rules. biking is my primary means of transportation and I ride to work daily. I've got no problem with enforcement but isn't this putting the cart in front of the horse?
I am a proud scofflaw waiting to be Novak'd and I know my day is coming, accident or enforcement. But this highlights how cyclists are stuck between a rock and hard place with regards to obeying rules. Another prime example of this is M st. through Georgetown. It's a parking lot during the evening rush hour and with lots of illegal parked cars in the curb lane cyclists are forced to weave through traffic between lanes. It's illegal and unsafe but I do it rather than going a block or two north of M street just to head west.
So I say enforce away and we'll gladly pay (clever, no?) but do us cyclists a favor and put every single bit of that revenue into improving cycling routes so we can all go about lives.
[ report this ]
I agree that this citation was ridiculous, but it's only a block and there are two rarely crowded sidewalks...not that difficult to detour on a sidewalk for one block. Just be curteous to the pedestrians!
[ report this ]
"As a cyclist, I think this is fine. Going through stop signs and red lights when it's completely clear are okay—I really believe—but biking on a one-way-street is not cool."
I agree. When you go through a stop sign or red light (safely, when it's clear, and never at such a speed that you can't know what's coming before you enter intersection), you're able to know exactly what's coming and whether the intersection will be clear for the entire time you'll be in it. When you go the wrong way on a one-way street, you are making a prediction that for the next few minutes, there won't be cars coming down it, or a garbage truck, or several cyclists going the right way. And you have no way of knowing if those predictions will actually be correct.
On those occasions when you need to get someplace that is down a one-way street, get on the sidewalk for the block or two it takes to get where you're going.
[ report this ]
I was caught in this this morning too. I actually usually take the sidewalk on this stretch, but it was thronged with pedestrians this morning, and from the comments I've read before on DCist, everyone walking hates bikes on sidewalks. I didn't want to irritate people, and since there's construction on V Street between New Hampshire and 16th Street right now, this was the safest option.
Also, that stretch of New Hampshire is at least twice as wide as necessary for a one lane one-way street, and is rarely used at that hour of the morning. While sitting there for 30 minutes to get my ticket (he was not the fastest ticket-writer, and there were a lot of us), I saw fewer cars drive by than cyclists told to pull over.
Also, those lucky ones who saw my frantic waving and turned around while the officer wasn't looking -- you're welcome.
Here are my pics from this morning on flickr.
[ report this ]
When you go the wrong way on a one-way street, you are making a prediction that for the next few minutes
A few minutes to go 2 blocks? Who's on the bike? Estelle Getty?
[ report this ]
THANKS BE TO GOD! That the police are finally on those bikers. I mean if the police should be worried about anything in this town, if they should set up sting operations, and road blocks, and pull people over, it should be cyclists with little helmets and khakis! Those cyclists are the most dangerous things on the streets. When something goes bump in my house at night, I jump up looking for my commemorative Heller handgun thinking "there must be cyclist in the house!"
[ report this ]
Correction: 14th does have a bike lane, but not until SOUTH of U Street .
Therefore, when one is biking south, they have no choice but to either share either 14th or 16th street with cars (and trucks and buses), or take the New Hampshire Ave cut through.
[ report this ]
Oh, and that cop really needs to bike more.
[ report this ]
I say, leave the cyclists alone, and go after the criminals responsible for the uptick in robberies in Columbia Heights.
[ report this ]
While I am generally happy to see the MPD enforcing traffic violations, the priority should be on DRIVERS, not cyclists or pedestrians. We need to discourage the aggressive, reckless driving that takes place all over this city. Yes, cyclists can be aggressive and reckless too. However, most are not and even when cyclists are aggressive or reckless, the potential they have to harm someone other than themselves is far less when compared to a car. In addition, the city should be doing everything possible to DISCOURAGE people from driving and ENCOURAGE people to ride bikes or walk. Biking and walking is healthier, doesn't pollute, doesn't require gas, and greatly reduces traffic congestion. Finally, we have issues in DC right now that are far more serious than a few cyclists riding the wrong way down a one way street. Does anyone ever visit Trinidad? Anyone aware of the HUGE spike in crime that is occurring in wards 4 and 5? An innocent 13 year-old was killed just a week ago and this is what the MPD is spending their time on? Give me a break!
[ report this ]
i think the pic of the biker with her arms crossed sums up all of the arguments succinctly
[ report this ]
how much were the tickets in comparison to, oh let's say, hitting a pedestrian with my 'vette and driving away? i'd like to know which infraction will be lighter on my pocketbook before heading out tomorrow morning for work.
[ report this ]
"If you use that route to get to Dupont, we recommend turning right on V, crossing 16th and turning left onto 17th then right on NH. It's a bit out of the way, but the route is on low volume streets and completely legal."
Make sure you say hello to your friends at the Police Station when you do. You can't miss the them; they are usually double parked and/or opening a door.
PS. The cop misswrote my name and address yesterday morning. So, I shall not be paying the $25 fine. ( Which I hear is only half of what Novak is fined for his hit and run...)
[ report this ]
As Eric said ... take 17th. It's one way heading south. Not sure how much traffic goes through there, but since it is one way you can take up the lane in order to be seen by all other traffic. Just don't dawdle ... you don't want to upset the morning racers, err commuters.
[ report this ]
The gist of the comments is that people being punished for breaking the law is bad. That makes my head hurt.
[ report this ]
So fucking stupid...why isnt captain donut out there on Friday and Saturday nights ticketing the fuckwad motorcyclists that speed up and down U street and rev their engines at stop lights all night? I agree w/the 17th street idea though, real easy way to get to NH.
[ report this ]
Why did bikers even bother to stop? There's no way MPD is going to be able to chase someone down with all the traffic on U and 16th...
[ report this ]
the point about the width of this road is quite salient here.
there's no reason that the stretch of new hampshire between 15th and 17th, though a one-way road, couldn't have bike lanes going both ways it's super super wide. wide enough for a 3 lane road in there.
use the money from these tickets to paint the lanes, ddot. and then remember, these people who are biking are your friends. they're the ones who WANT to live in this city and pay taxes. don't scare them away with silly sting operations.
[ report this ]
As a cyclist, I'm thrilled to see a picture of a cop *gasp* actually enforcing traffic laws. The majority of bikers in this town are morons and won't stop riding against traffic on one-way streets until they face the consistent threat of a ticket.
However, if you step up enforcement for cyclists, you also have to do it for the idiot drivers who don't give a shit about operating their 3,000-pound hunks of steel in a way that won't kill people.
[ report this ]
As a cyclist, I think this is fairly obvious, ride the wrong way down a one way street