DCist T-Shirts
dcistshirt.jpg
About DCist

DCist is a website about Washington, D.C. More

Editor: Sommer Mathis Publisher: Gothamist

About | Advertising | Archive | Contact | Mobile | Photos | Staff | Subscribe

Categories
DCist Exposed Photography Show -- Feb 20-Mar 7
Favorites
Contribute

Latest tip:

There is a suspicious package being investigated near 12th and D St SW, in front of the new Homel [more]

 

Latest link:

 

Latest Photo:

 

Recent Comments
Subscribe
Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from DCist.
Overheard
Voting Rights
Public Calendar
Links

October 2, 2008

Transit on Thursday: Are You Satisfied?

2008_1002_metrocenter.jpgFor all its foibles, Metro is still something most of the capital region wants to take pride in. Sure, all the news lately about the Metro funding bill touts the importance of federal workers riding the rails on a daily basis - but when it comes down to it, Metro in general is something beloved by most area residents, regardless of where they work.

Metro conducted one of its Customer Satisfaction Measures over the past couple of months. Over 80 percent of respondents found Metrorail satisfactory. There's even more love to be found in the survey: as pointed out in the Examiner's writeup of the results, a large majority of people feel safe on Metro - 85 percent of bus riders and 89 percent of rail riders, to be exact. It's a good number, considering last year's rash of bus accidents and the fact that robberies in the system have been on the rise this year. Other large city subway systems have lower figures in the same categories. (For instance, levels of perceived safety on New York subway lines have been hovering close to 50 percent since 2005. Philadelphia has also seen a rash of incredibly violent crime in SEPTA trains and facilities recently.)

But just like anything you love, sometimes you need to be the one to tell them the awful truths. For instance, only a slim majority of Metro users surveyed (54 percent) use the WMATA website to get information about trains and buses. We know plenty of folks who don't even realize that you can get real time train arrivals at any station. It's a disappointing figure and a sign that Metro could benefit from some enhanced web capabilities - for instance, the eventual integration of Metrorail with Google Transit should help spur activity.

Photo by NCinDC.

A few other interesting tidbits from the survey:

  • A staggering 98 percent of rail riders have one or more cars in their households. The repercussions here are two-fold - first, it is certainly a good thing that Metro is attracting such a high number of people who could conceivably be driving to work and other activities. On the other hand, the figure is indicative of the breakneck pace that Metro seems to be on, ridership-wise. If this number stays steady (or rises), Metro will easily smash their projection of nearly one million riders per day in the near future.
  • About 80 percent of rail and bus riders are employed; but whereas 83 percent of Metrorail riders have a college degree, only 56 percent of Metrobus riders are college educated. Obviously, such a gap in education is very interesting; is it a matter of Metrobus simply reaching more areas than Metrorail, or is it indicative of a wider social gap in public transportation availability?
  • Finally, you know it, we know it. Metro's oft-pathetic bus service earned only a 63 percent satisfaction rate.
If anything, the figures provide a concrete affirmation of most of what we think about Metro - that is, we can't turn away from it. But it could stand to be better to us.

Around a thousand bus and rail riders were surveyed for the CSM over the past couple of months. If anyone out there was one of the lucky ones surveyed, do feel free to share your experience in the comments.

Now You Can Plan The Rest of Your Weekend Activities: It's no secret that Metro delays are part and parcel of the typical Washingtonian weekend. But at least WMATA has taken the proactive step of releasing the entire schedule for weekend work one month in advance, ranging all the way to the first weekend in November. Before, the most amount of notice for such typical work was three or four days. This month, every line is affected, with the notable exception of the Yellow line (of course, the last two months have seen the Yellow line have its fair share of track work). Upcoming delays consist entirely of single tracking due to track maintenance; as usual, the agency recommends that passengers add an additional 20 minutes to their weekend commutes because of the work. There's also little work that will affect folks traveling between central portions of the city - but if you're planning to venture out to the 'burbs, do check the schedule. If you don't, no worries - we'll keep you posted.

File Under Recommended Listening: We've always been a big fan of Adam Tuss's Metro reporting, and he hasn't disappointed with his recent series of audio reports on our flailing rail system. While we're fairly certain that if you're reading this, you're well aware of the material that Tuss covers in Parts I, IV, and V. But Tuss's reports on 2x4s holding up Metro platforms (Part III) and the perils of the success of MetroAccess, an issue which we noted back in May (Part VI) are really enlightening.

Engines and Cabooses: Metro facing Justice Department discrimination suit... Comparing the Underground and the Metro - basic finding? The Underground's way bigger... Some Fairfax County buses returning to normal service... Metro to open early on Sunday to accommodate the Army ten-miler... Funds allocated to rail improvements between Richmond and D.C. will increase currently sluggish performance - and are a bargain at $13 million... With Metro expansion on the way, Loudoun County begins to talk public transit... D.C. earns grant to fund community trails.

Email This Entry







Advertisement: DCist Continues Below!

Comments (16) [rss]

I call shenanigans on the figure of 98% of riders have 1 or more cars.

 

Good post. For all the grief people give Metro, it's still a clean, safe an efficient way to get around town.

 

This kind of went by under the radar screen, but in the Senate bailout bill last that was passed last night, they put in a provision for giving tax credits for employers that give benefits to employees who bike to work.

 

It's not 98% of riders that have 1 or more cars.

It's 98% of riders that responded to the survey. All of the results need to be viewed through that lens.

 

Still, shenanigans must be called and no points awarded, gotta be a typo.

 

It's 98% of riders that responded to the survey. All of the results need to be viewed through that lens.

If that's the case, then I'm calling shenanigans on the representativeness of their sample. Almost 40% of DC households do not have a car - yet they only represent 2% of Metro's riders?

Note to WMATA's survey people - standing outside the Vienna park and ride lot is not going to give you a representative sample.

 

It looks like this article squeaked into the Post just after you put this Transit on Thursday together . . .

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/10/02/AR2008100201740.html?tid=informbox

I mean, it's a lawsuit that involves Metro, cultural clashes, and pants ... that's a DCist natural!

 

For what it's worth, I got a survey today as I entered my metro stop.

If you go on the Metro website and find the survey results (in the end I had to google for it, and I've already lost the address) it truly does say that 98% of metro rail riders come from households with at least one car (the bus riders came in at 80% with cars). I thought perhaps it was an examiner typo too (they are infamous for "accidentally" reading stats to support a crazy pro-car POV), but the raw data says 98%. That just can't be accurate though.

 

Nate: Check the first story in the Engines and Cabooses section.

For everyone else thinking about the car percentage issue: keep in mind two things. First, while 98% seems like an absurdly high number, look at the breakdown of where surveys could come from. Car ownership ratios in Maryland and Virginia are going to be somewhere between 90 and 100 percent. And blockski, your claim that "almost 40% of DC households do not have a car" tells me nothing other than the fact that almost 60% of District residents (a fair majority) do own a car. Maybe Metro's cold calls caught a majority of Marylanders and Virginians, and the few Washingtonians they did talk to had a car?

Secondly, as Politburo has adeptly pointed out, this is simply a survey of around one thousand riders, not a comprehensive breakdown of the hundreds of thousands that ride every day.

All that said, it is an eyeopening number - I certainly wouldn't have guessed a figure anywhere near it.

 

Oops, totally missed that.

Still . . . .pants!

 

Aaron,

Your scenario is certainly plausible, but it doesn't make for a representative sample. The survey has a huge hole in its validity if the sample is not representative.

The Census says there are 282,894 households in DC. Average persons per household is 2.16. This isn't the most valid math, but if you take 40% of 282,894 and multiply that by 2.16, that's more than 244,000 people living without a car in DC. Metrorail's daily ridership is something like 800,000 unlinked trips per day, and APTA's ballpark multiplier to get the number of individual people is .45, thus that 800,000 trips represents 360,000 individuals riding metro each day.

244,000 DC residents without cars. 360,000 individuals riding metro. And the overlap is only 2%? 2% of that 360,000 is only 7,200 people. Only 7,200 of those 244,000 ride Metro?

This just doesn't pass the smell test. I'm not saying their results are wrong (I'm sure they're reporting exactly what responses they got), I'm saying their methodology looks like it was horribly inaccurate.

 

56 percent of Metrobus riders are college educated? uh... incorrect. Maybe 56 percent are high school grads, but not sure about that.

 

The sampling methodology seems very suspect. Obviously the survey didn't do a very good job surveying less affluent Metro riders, in DC particularly.

 

what do those tax benefits look like for employers that give benefits to employees that cycle? and what do the employee benefits have to look like to qualify?

 

Obviously the survey didn't do a very good job surveying less affluent Metro riders, in DC particularly.

Kinda tough surveying someone sleeping and taking up two seats, making booty calls, or rocking out to Lil Wayne, innit?

 

yeah, i wanna hear more about the tax breaks for bikers! gimme my money!

 
Post a comment (Comment Policy)

2003-2009 Gothamist LLC. All rights reserved. Terms of Use & Privacy Policy. We use MovableType.

Site Meter