October 27, 2008
The Magnetic Fields @ Lisner Auditorium
Written by DCist contributor Dave Weigel
The Magnetic Fields have a song called “Washington, D.C.” It’s not actually about Washington, per se. The city is a collection of incidental, touristy, democratic details, and what makes it important to vocalist Claudia Gonson is that it’s “where my baby lives, that’s all.” So it’s fitting that the band put the song together as an afterthought. Gonson walked on the stage for an encore, promised the audience an a cappella version, and got interrupted by the arrival of the rest of the band.
”I told them I would sing ‘Washington, D.C.!’” Gonson said, laughing. “And then you came out!”
”I can’t hear you,” said Merritt. He really couldn’t. He has hyperacusis and plugs his ears to block out loud noise.
The two founders of the Magnetic Fields looked at each other, unblinking. Gonson made her move. “I’ll sing the first verse.” She played it haltingly, hitting her notes on the piano as if she was tutoring an especially rhythmic and invisible pupil.
”If we knew we’d be in Washington,” said Merritt, “we probably would have rehearsed that song.”
That was Sunday’s Magnetic Fields show at Lisner Auditorium. Gonson, game and funny, told stories and joked about the origins of the band’s songs. Merritt, looking as gnomish as one can without hobbit DNA, grimaced and cradled his bouzouki. “More anecdotes!” he snarked when Gonson told a story about the band’s lost luggage. He started to explain how the song “California Girls” began with a misunderstanding at a Jefferson Airplane show, and a heckler yelled out “Not Starship?”
”No, dear,” said Gonson.
”Security!” said Merritt. He was kidding, sort of, but he seemed to be longing for the audience to find refuge beyond some sound-proof glass.
The audience couldn’t have enjoyed it all more. This is city of hipsters who don’t dance; here is a band that plays to hipsters in seated auditoriums. (“The theater circuit,” as Gonson called it.) The band was matched perfectly by opener Shugo Tokumaru, a 27-year old folk-pop phenom from Tokyo who sounds like an embryonic Sufjan Stevens. At 8 p.m., Tokumaru clambered up onto a stool, barefoot, and started picking out the first of a dozen intricate, pretty melodies. His drummer and two mutli-instrumentalists played softly through songs that ranged from McCartney-ish pop to 12-bar blues, never sounding more dangerous than a band of Disney animals might sound if they decided to pursue careers in indie rock. Tokumaru won the room over easily; he was just what the family therapist ordered.
And Tokumaru, at his poppiest, was more boisterous than the main act. Washington, D.C. was the last stop on the band’s tour for Distortion, an album Merritt recorded in tribute to the Jesus and Mary Chain. On the record, every instrument—guitar, accordion, piano—is slathered in gunky feedback. Live, the band is stripped down to Gonson’s piano, Merritt’s bouzouki, Sam Davol’s cello, John Woo’s guitar, and the occasional lead and harmony vocals of Shirley Simms. The Distortion songs were scrubbed clean and turned into alternately silly and haunting chamber music. “The Nun’s Litany” morphed from surf music into a sad, cello-driven lament from a chaste woman who dreams of letting loose. “Old Fools”, plenty beautiful in its studio form, became as mournful as the old Fields standard “Papa Was a Rodeo”.
That song, and the handful of Fields songs not from Distortion or side projects, were played on a sliding scale. Spare songs became incredibly spare. “The Book of Love” (now, horrifyingly, a selection on iTunes’ “Indie Wedding” playlist) was stripped down to bouzouki and Woo’s slide guitar. “Take Ecstacy With Me” was handed from Merritt to Gonson, who wrung all the heartbreak out of the lyrics as Davol sawed away on his cello.
Merritt’s misery aside, the show never stayed dark for two songs in a row. It ended with real joy when Merritt and Gonson uncorked “Yeah! Oh, Yeah!”, an ironic anti-love song (“Are you reaching for your life? Could you really kill your wife!”) that he sang in a James Cagney voice and she sang dancing around the stage in what she called “Edward Gorey or Jules Feiffer” contortions. There was sarcasm, sure, and there was some kind of cloud over the frontman, but a lot of that is artiface. This is happy music by and for miserable people.
”We’re very happy to be in Washington,” said Gonson as the show wrapped up.
“We’re especially happy,” said Merriit, “not to be in Philadelphia.”






[ report this ]
The show was fun, but I was a bit disappointed that they played the songs from the new album "cleanly". The album is called Distortions! I wanted some friggin' feedback! But this comes from a hipster who likes to boogie in her seat..
The chatter was amusing, but in a Prairie Home Companion type of way- which made me shudder a bit. I saw the same tousled hair, professorial glasses and jackets at Sarah Vowell's show last Thursday.
[ report this ]
I think it's "are you reaching for a knife?"
Great show, though. Incredibly weird and lovely.
[ report this ]
Distortion and feedback are two different things.
[ report this ]
Love the band but, come on, the show was very, very disappointing. Just because a song is dark doesn't mean it has to be played like a dirge, or pretentiously, like every note is the most important in the world. I mean let's have a little fun too. Gonson's jabber was mostly annoying. Merritt was funny but obviously under the weather. Tvc has it right about there being no distortion in the songs from "Distortion."
All the credit in the world to Merritt for great writing and to the band for fantastic studio work. But it just doesn't translate into a good live show.
First time in my life I liked the opening act more than the band I came to see. Maybe the second half was better. I wouldn't know, because we left.
[ report this ]
Opinions are like assholes, and I really don't get this band's popularity. I always assumed their following around here was primarily a result of the Washington DC song.
[ report this ]
If I were to just take the songs, I'd say this was a pretty good show. If I took the entire performance as a whole, I'm pretty disappointed. The inane chatter was one thing, endearing at first, then increasingly grating as the night went on. It slowed the flow of the show down to a crawl. Taking about an hour to do about 12 songs. Then they had the audacity to do an intermission. To come back for another 30 minutes. If you would shut up and play the songs, maybe work out a set list before hand and work on some transitions, you could do the whole set quicker.
I feel bad Stephin Merrit was sick. But you know what, be a professional and fight through itdon't let the audience know you're sick. The show must go on. Certainly don't stop the set to FUMBLE WITH THROAT LOZENGES... TWICE!
Also, as some above posters noted, some changes in instrumentation and arrangement would have been nice. With the scarce instrumentation they presented last night, all the songs started to sound the same.
Other than these complaints, it was wonderful to see them, and to hear "Papa Was a Rodeo" et. al.
[ report this ]
as a magnetic fields fan, i came with low expectations so i was not disappointed.
[ report this ]
I thought the show was incredible, the chatter charming, the opening act perfect and the lack of distortion on the new songs great (if you wanted to hear the song exactly like it is on the album, listen to the album). I could have sat in that uncomfortable seat and listened to them play every song he's ever written.
[ report this ]
I'm with you cohi.
I'm a big fan and I thought it was really cool to hear all the songs totally reimagined. Some of them didn't really stand up ("Drive On, Driver" which I love on the album and didn't love last night) and some really did ("All My Little Words" which was beautiful and sad.)
I can see that the show wasn't for everyone, but personally I loved it. I wish I could buy an un-distorted live version of "Distortion."