Out of Frame: The Messenger

2009_11_13_themessenger.jpg The Messenger starts with loss, as Staff Sergeant Will Montgomery (Ben Foster) has one last bittersweet meeting with his girlfriend, who met another man while he was off to war. It's a gentle way of ushering the audience into a movie that is all about loss on a larger scale. For soon after his return from the war, with injuries that nearly took away an eye and his ability to walk, Montgomery is assigned to the Army's Casualty Notification service, bringing news of the deaths of soldiers in the field to their families back home.

It's an assignment no one wants, and why would they? Being the bearers of the worst possible news, these soldiers regularly witness the first, strongest rush of grief — and the devastated, sometimes violent, reactions that come with it. The danger of someone shooting the messenger isn't just metaphorical here. It's emotionally taxing work, and it's no wonder that Montgomery's partner, Captain Tony Stone (Woody Harrelson), a seasoned veteran of Casualty Notification, is a recovering alcoholic. How could you deliver that kind of news and witness that kind of pain and not need something to take the edge off?

Experienced screenwriter Oren Moverman (Jesus' Son, I'm Not There) makes a confident debut in the director's chair here. He wisely avoids any mention of politics or the legitimacy of the wars being fought. His soldiers don't feel like mouthpieces for a writer's anti-war agenda; they feel like soldiers. Stone looks at Montgomery with a degree of envy for the Staff Sergeant's valor in battle; as a veteran of the first Gulf War, Stone didn't see much action. These men are trained to be warriors, and want to put that training to the test.

Similarly, when Stone declares that he thinks that the funeral of every dead soldier should be televised, and that the President should regularly eulogize at them, it's not that he wants people to feel the costs of war, or for the President to feel more empathy for what he's sending these young men and women to do. Stone just thinks people should get used to the idea that war equals death. After all, it would make his job a little easier if people weren't so shocked by the news he brings.

Harrelson delivers what is quite possibly the finest performance of his career, largely because Moverman allows him to work the dramatic chops he has displayed sporadically throughout his career, while still letting him to do what he does best, be funny. What comedy there is — mostly in Stone's tendency to blow off steam inappropriately while off-duty — is understated and never clashes with the solemnity that dominates the movie.

As good as Harrelson is, the movie belongs to Foster, an actor of frightening intensity who has sadly only occasionally been given the chance to show just how good he is. Moverman gives him the star turn here, and he quietly dazzles. Foster's beautiful performance througout lies deep in his eyes and in the subtle nervous mannerisms that threaten to crack his façade.

Montgomery is a model soldier always looking for a challenge: he insists that he take the lead on only the second notification the two men go on together, declaring that when he's given an assignment, he does it. But his on-duty stoicism masks a man dealing — badly — with intense losses of his own. When he delivers news of a soldier's death to a new widow (Samantha Morton), he recognizes in her calm and gracious response the same mask he wears every day.

The uncomfortable relationship these two are drawn into, which is less a romance than two broken people cautiously trying to find a place where it's safe to let their guard down, is yet another in a long list of examples of just how easily The Messenger could have gone wrong, yet it never does. A Hollywood-ized version of this movie might have thrown the two into a full-blown affair, but Moverman isn't interested in dressing things up for unlikely but dramatic effects.

The Messenger drives home the point that war is a losing proposition, which has nothing to do with who is victorious on the battlefield. They're the everyday losses of life, of family, of friends. The film is a moving and human reflection on the costs of war, and a deeply respectful look at the work done by the rank and file of the armed forces, both overseas and at home. It isn't a political film, and it isn't even necessarily an anti-war film. It's just about the legacy that war leaves behind, for those that fight it, and those who love them. Because even in victory, loss is still inevitable.

The Messenger opens today at E Street and Bethesda Row.
View the trailer.

Email This Entry


Comments (5) [rss]

Great review! I was interested but a bit skeptical when I saw the trailer last night. You review allayed any qualms I had about seeing it.

Harrelson was on the Colbert Report last night: http://www.colbertnation.com/the-colbert-report-videos/255255/november-12-2009/woody-harrelson

The best part was Colbert shaving Woody's head while the two of them sing The Star-Spangled Banner in two-part harmony: http://www.colbertnation.com/the-colbert-report-videos/255256/november-12-2009/sign-off---stephen-shaves-woody-s-head

This bit and the review actually make me want to see this film, and I usually only go for more escapist fare.


I agree; great review.

I really want this film to work. The American public need to hold those who act on their behalf responsible when their injudicious decisions kill our young.

Call me what you may, but an absolute hatred of George W. Bush, and his staff that lead us into Iraq, burns within me.

user-pic

Excellent review, as always. That's so true about Ben Foster, too! I was truly stunned with his performance in 3:10 to Yuma. It's nice see him in more leading roles now.

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

About DCist

DCist is a website about Washington, D.C. More

Editor: Sommer Mathis Publisher: Gothamist

Twitter

Contribute

Latest Tip:

Check out local Singer/Songwriter Todd Wright's new project 40x40. He's writing recording and relea
[more]

Latest Photo:

Recent Comments

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from DCist.

All Our RSS