Quantcast

Head of MLK Memorial Unhappy With Quote Change

02.13.2012_mlk.jpg
Photo by joelogon

Plenty of people may have been happy when Interior Secretary Ken Salazar agreed to change a controversial quote on the new Martin Luther King, Jr. Memorial, but the man in charge of the foundation that raised the money to build it certainly isn't one.

The AP reports that Harry E. Johnson Sr., president and CEO of the Martin Luther Jr. National Memorial Project Foundation, is unhappy that Salazar is moving ahead with changing a paraphrased quote on the memorial, claiming that the new quote will have to be inscribed on a new block of granite that won't match that which was used for the memorial:

Fixing the quote will likely involve cutting into the monument several inches around the inscription to remove a block of granite and replacing it with another piece for engraving. It’s unclear how much the work would cost. Echoing statements from the architect of the foundation, Johnson said the change threatens the monument’s design and structure.

“While we understand the position of the National Park Service,” the statement said, “we are confident that our legion of donors, volunteers and supporters will agree that a less intrusive solution should be explored to ensure the sanctity of the iconic symbol we have come to cherish is not threatened.”

The "Drum Major quote," as the quotation is known, was lifted from a 1968 sermon King delivered at Ebenezer Baptist Church in Atlanta. The monument, which was unveiled late last year, reads: “I was a drum major for justice, peace and righteousness." Critics have noted that the line was actually paraphrased from several sentences. The full passage, which will now be chiseled on the monument's base, reads: “Yes, if you want to say that I was a drum major, say that I was a drum major for justice. Say that I was a drum major for peace. I was a drum major for righteousness. And all of the other shallow things will not matter.”

Salazar said that the change would take a year to complete.

Contact the author of this article or email tips@dcist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • DonPancho

    Just chop it all out and drill in a plaque that reads "Whatever".

    The MLK Memorial: A great heaving boulder of bickering and angst.

  • Peanut_Butter

    Easy fix: add "..." after Justice, cover up "and", and add "..." in its place.  Then at the head, add the all-important "If" clause which qualifies the current quote.

  • I may be stupid, but why bother trying to match the granite? Being close but not quite always looks bad. I'd say put in something completely different, like black marble or bronze. Something that will complement. Trying to match it will look like when someone tries to paint over graffiti on the side of a building.

  • guestymcspanky

     Why don't they just shave an inch off the entire side.  I'd think that would be far less visually jarring than a granite almostmatch or altering than gluing on a black marble/bronze panel.

  • Guest

    They may want to fix all of the bad quotes while they are at it.

    How about: "I am not interested in power for power's sake, but I'm interested in power that is moral, that is right and that is good."

    Which was carved: I'm interested in power

    How about: "I want to be the white man's brother, not his brother-in-law.

    Which was carved: I want to be white.

  • Strom Thurmond

    LOL

  • Peanut_Butter

    How does one paraphrase a quote, and out of context, and do so in a major location like that?  What a catastrophe.

  • wizzyliz

    You mean like this?

    http://assets.diylol.com/hfs/7... 

  • AMDCer

    Some of our best monuments have mis-matched granite. Just ask the Washington Monument...

  • Is That Your Bag?

    That awesome moment when you see the look on a tourist's face (particularly one in your own family) after you tell them that the Washington Monument is discolored because of "The Great DC Flood of 1826"

  • wizzyliz

    Nah, I tell them aliens used laser beams to knock it down. After we killed them off we had it rebuilt with pieces of their mothership.

  • Johnson said the change threatens the monument’s design and structure.

    Says the guy who carelessly edited a quote and had it inscribed in f**king GRANITE without running it by the right people, inadvertently changing the meaning of said quote, the tone of the entire memorial, and created a ridiculous controversy which completely stole the spotlight for the entire first year of the memorial's existence. Harry Johnson is the reason generations people will be telling tourists: "did you know they f**ked up the first quote, that's why you see that line around the rock there..." 

    I guess foundation money guys have to have massive balls, both to ask for money all day, and to pretend that the fix for their mistake is the problem, as opposed to the mistake itself. They have to fix it Harry- you f**ked it up man.

  • wizzyliz

    "Head of MLK Memorial" - I'd be unhappy too with a big scowl on my face for generations to see.

  • CJ_Scudworth

    Also, he should get that scoliosis checked out.

  • Pete_eats

    I dunno.. that's the look on every drum major I've ever seen.

  • Guest
  • I have a dream that one day all of God's granite, black granite and white granite, red granite and pink granite, will be able to join together on the same monument and we can sing in the words of the old spiritual:

    Free at last! Free at last! Thank God Almighty, we are free at last from this stupid f**king nontroversy!

  • But I've been to the mountaintop ... and it was only one kind of granite.

  • dcvoterboy

    Check out the Post's Editorial today on this topic, as they call out the irony of Mr. Johnson's current complaint given the fact that he was the one that edited out 37 of the 47 words in the original quote (which the original plans had included the full quote) without telling anyone; and that's how we got here in the first place.

  • So let Harry pay for it out of pocket. If he needs some extra cash, plenty of porn companies would hire him with a name like that.

  • CJ_Scudworth

    Plenty of porn companies would hire him with a name like that.

    In the '70s maybe. Good luck trying to find any hairy johnsons in today's industry.

  • Guest

    Porn Knows No Seasons

    Hirsutism pornography involves conspicuous amounts of body and/or pubic hair. The models may be partially shaven, show body hair stubble or be completely unshaven, with an emphasis on the socially tabooed armpit hair. The latter are sometimes marketed as "Hippies" and can be connected with Naturism. Because of the increased trend toward total depilation in contemporary pornography, the presence of any pubic hair at all on a model, even when groomed, is sometimes considered as making the model "hairy". 

    Hirsutism or frazonism is the excessive hairiness on women in those parts of the body where terminal hair does not normally occur or is minimal - for example, a beard or chest hair. It refers to a male pattern of body hair (androgenic hair) and it is therefore primarily of cosmetic and psychological concern. Hirsutism is a symptom rather than a disease and may be a sign of a more serious medical condition, especially if it develops well after puberty. The amount and location of the hair is measured by a Ferriman-Gallwey score.

  • I blame the younger people with their hippety-hop music and their Snoopy Poop Dog and their Enema Man and their depilatories. Also 9/11.

  • I'm just here for the snark

    I hear he just signed a deal to pronote Nads.

  • I'm just here for the snark

    Never an IG arround when you need one.

  • MmmCashews

    I like how the organization still emailed me for money long after the project was completed, probably to sell excess premium items and put the money back into the fraternity that started the Foundation.

  • mommyworks

    The foundation will have to pay for the upkeep of the memorial (graffiti abatement, cleaning, patchwork to physical damage) so they will need a continuous cash flow for NPS fees. At the office we provide a variety of management services and one of our clients is a memorial and those things are expensive to keep in good order.  Graffiti abatement is a large problem and the park service does a good job at cleaning it up ASAP for the memorials in their care but there is a fee for service.  Mr. Johnson is probably more ticked that he will have to pay to have his mistake fixed out of the  foundation. This will not make donors too pleased. 

  • Guest


    graffiti abatement?

    I think you mean enjoying the diversity of expressions made by 'Street Artists". 

  • Well, the donors should have thought of that before they hired a total dick for a CEO. I mean, his name pretty much spells it out for you.

  • mommyworks

    All jokes aside, you are absolutely correct. This is management companies get this kind of work when the board of this foundation realizes that this guy is not good for PR therefore fundraising they will ditch him for a firm that will manage the memorial. These egotistical chuckleheads use the memorial as an extension of themselves rather than honoring the intended person or group.

  • About the best you can say for this guy is that he probably didn't rape any teenage boys in the lockerroom shower. Probably.

  • scooterj2003

    I think Johnson is just afraid that the new granite, if it doesn't match the old granite perfectly, will just serve to perpetually highlight the mistake that he made in approving the original quote.  So I don't blame him for objecting.  On the other hand, the quote, as it is engraved now, threatens the integrity of the memorial more than an unmatched piece of granite would. 

  • CJ_Scudworth

    Plus we can always come up with some mumbo-jumbo BS after the fact about how the mismatched granite symbolizes the complexity of MLK's soul.

  • Pete_eats

    I think the post-modern historian speak is "complicates the standard King narrative."

  • I'm just here for the snark

    We're all afraid of new granite at first, but once you work it, it will fit right in.

  • I'm just here for the snark

    "Harry E. Johnson"

    *Giggle*

  • vroomen

    Maybe you shouldn't have screwed it up in the first place then, fella...

  • bingo

  • Seriously. This is what happens when you fire all the editors to "save money." What's the price quote on fixing this thing anyway?

  • DCTransplant

    $51 million and the work will take several years, during which the memorial will be closed to the public.

  • Shouldn't they appoint a blue ribbon panel and send them on a fact-finding mission to London, Paris, Rome, Venice, Tokyo, and Hong Kong to see how those jurisdictions deal with memorial engraving f**kups?

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@dcist.com
dcist official merch