A life-size foam replica of an ancient English icon just doesn’t “fit” on the site of a new national park with natural right there in the name—which was a polite way of saying that Foamhenge had to go.

Mark Cline, an artist and something of a roadside attraction impresario, built the Stonehenge replica back in 2004, supposedly as an April Fool’s joke. But it quickly became a tourist attraction in Rockbridge County, Virginia.

A few years later, the surrounding area—home to Natural Bridge, a 215-foot-tall limestone arch whose previous owners include Thomas Jefferson and King George III—was put up for sale. After a concerted effort to ensure the preservation of the bridge and its surroundings, the nonprofit Virginia Conservation Legacy Fund has worked to get it designated as a state park. The path was rocky, but Natural Bridge State Park is set to become Virginia’s 37th state park this fall.

And officials decided that Foamhenge would stick out like a sore set of foam thumbs—telling Cline that the attraction doesn’t “fit” with the mission of the new state park, according to the Richmond Times-Dispatch.

He set about trying to give away Foamhenge to a town that needed a tourism boost, but eventually settled on Cox Farms, located in Centreville, a part of Fairfax County. The 116-acre farm is best known for its annual Fall Festival.

“We feel like we’ve got a nice little cult following, and we thought the two would mingle well,” Lucas Cox, “co-farmer-in-chief” at Cox Farms, told the Richmond Times-Dispatch. The attraction will be installed after the end of this year’s festival.

To relive the original experience, though, Cline gave one final tour on site.